The Pulse
Bain says retail market share does not guarantee AI shopping visibility
Bain's analysis found that, in many retail categories, specialists often appear in AI shopping answers more than their market share would suggest. The firm also found growing use of AI assistants during shopping, though trust in AI-completed purchases remains limited.

In many retail categories, specialists often appear in AI shopping answers more than their market share would suggest, and market share alone no longer guarantees a retailer a place in those answers, according to an analysis by Bain & Company. The finding comes as more consumers report using AI assistants during their shopping journeys.
Source prnewswire.com
The analysis covered more than 4,400 shopping prompts across four retail categories and over 300,000 unique runs across the most-used large language models, using data from Profound. Bain examined which retailers appeared in the answers and found that, for many retail verticals, category specialists often over-indexed relative to their market share compared with general retailers.
Shopping use is rising
Nearly 33% of US consumers and 36% of European consumers say they use AI assistants for some part of the shopping journey, according to Bain's Consumer Lab global survey. Those figures were 19% and 8%, respectively, in 2025.
AI assistant referrals account for less than 1% of retailers' overall web traffic, Bain says, but click-throughs and completed purchases do not capture all of the assistants' influence. Shoppers may use AI to research and summarize options before visiting a retailer's website independently.
The firm says AI referral traffic converts 90% better than non-AI traffic. Its report identifies third-party assistants, retailers' own assistants and customers' personal AI agents as areas where retailers will compete for traffic.
Trust favors retailer assistants
The survey found that 55% of global shoppers using AI do not fully trust it to complete a purchase. Consumers trust retailers' own assistants more than third-party assistants, at 21% and 12%, respectively, although Bain says that gap has narrowed as adoption of third-party agents has increased.
Only 27 of the 100 largest US retailers have their own customer-facing assistant, the firm found. It says retailers that rely solely on third-party assistants risk losing their primary customer relationship and the proprietary data associated with it.
Aaron Cheris, global head of Bain's retail practice, says visibility in AI answers changes constantly and requires ongoing attention. He argues that retailers are better positioned when they clearly describe their value to AI systems and organize around the shopping occasions customers care about.
Recommendations for retailers
Bain recommends that retailers test how visible they are in third-party assistants' answers for the products and occasions their customers care about. It also advises them to update important pages using customers' language and to consider how personal agents may prompt and behave differently from human shoppers.
For retailers without a launch plan for their own assistant in early 2027, the firm suggests considering a white-label product or an outsourced build. It also recommends assessing whether customer and product data is ready for personalization in such an assistant.
Finally, Bain advises retailers to assign responsibility for an agent-to-agent strategy and decide how open their own assistants should be to outside agents. Its checklist is intended for retailers to work through before the end of the holiday shopping season.
Sources
- Original source · Press release PR Newswire prnewswire.com
Related stories
- Architect Labs says its AI systems designed the Frostbite CPU
- ToolPulse researchers reconstruct AI agent workflows via cache traces
- TuringSpace test finds spatial action gaps in leading AI models
- Vals AI starts public tracker of misaligned model behavior
- OpenAI says agents completed 46% of delegated two-to-four-hour tasks