# Voyager finds mixed printability in 80 AI-generated 3D files

Published 2026-11-20 · AI.info Team · AI.info

> Voyager checked 80 files from eight AI 3D models for geometric problems that could affect printing. Hunyuan3D 3 produced 11 watertight files out of 11, while none of the 33 Meshy files passed the same test as delivered.

A geometry check of 80 AI-generated 3D files found that all 11 samples from Hunyuan3D 3 were watertight as delivered, while none of the 33 files from three [Meshy](https://ai.info/companies/meshy) versions passed that test, according to [Voyager](https://voyager.so/blog/ai-stl-generator). The company checked files from eight models for properties relevant to 3D printing, but did not slice or print any of them.

Published on Nov. 19 by Voyager co-founder Ravi Parikh, the comparison also found problems beyond holes, including stray fragments, overlapping parts and thin walls. Voyager builds a desktop app that runs several of the models tested.

## What the checks covered

A watertight mesh has every edge shared by exactly two faces, leaving no holes through which the inside of the object can leak. Voyager also examined the largest body separately from other pieces, a less stringent test than checking the whole file as delivered.

Seven of the models each produced 11 files: five first attempts at default settings, three runs requesting about 50,000 triangles and three second attempts. The remaining three files were coffee drippers generated by TRELLIS.2 from an image; the dripper input for every model was the same product image generated with Nano Banana Pro, rather than a photograph.

The team used trimesh 5.2.1 and Blender 5.2.1 to check the files returned by each model's API on Nov. 19. The tests were geometric checks rather than trials of finished prints.

## Closed files and loose pieces

Voyager reported that all 11 Hunyuan3D 3 files were watertight, although one dripper had a sealed hollow inside. For Rodin Gen-2.5, five of 11 whole files were watertight, but the main body was closed in all 11; six files had other pieces, including open slivers. Tripo H3.1 produced six watertight files out of 11 and nine with closed main bodies.

The checks also found crossing faces in seven of 11 Hunyuan3D 3 main bodies and four of 11 Rodin main bodies, according to Voyager. A closed mesh therefore was not the same as a file ready to print.

Voyager found no watertight files as delivered from Meshy versions 6, 7 and 7.1, Tripo P2 or TRELLIS.2. Among the Meshy files, eight of 33 had a closed main body once stray fragments were set aside.

## Thin walls and hollow skins

The separate Tripo P2 results showed objects assembled from overlapping parts. Of 115 larger parts across its 11 files, 44 were closed on their own, Voyager found; the analysis defined larger parts as bodies with at least 50 triangles.

For the three TRELLIS.2 drippers, the company found an outer surface and an inverted inner surface. Scaled to 10 cm wide, the median gap between them was 0.21 mm in each file. All three came from the same image, and Voyager cautioned that other TRELLIS.2 objects may differ.

When the default desk lamps were scaled to 10 cm on their longest side, Voyager estimated that 23% to 46% of the main body's surface was thinner than 0.8 mm for Hunyuan3D 3, Tripo H3.1 and all three Meshy versions. The equivalent estimate for Rodin Gen-2.5 was about 1%. The figures came from sampled faces on the largest body.

## Repair results

A scripted 0.5 mm voxel remesh closed all 33 Meshy files, Voyager reported. In 27 of those files, the repaired result kept its volume within 10% and moved the surface less than 0.5 mm on average.

All 80 files also arrived at about one or two units on their longest side, according to the analysis. The post notes that STL files have no units and that a slicer reads their numbers as millimetres.

## Sources

1. Original source · Blog post [Voyager](https://voyager.so/blog/ai-stl-generator) voyager.so

## In the tracker

- [Nano Banana](https://ai.info/tracker/models/nano-banana)
- [Nano Banana Pro](https://ai.info/tracker/models/nano-banana-pro)

## Related stories

- [MIT’s InstructMesh Lets Users Repair AI-Generated 3D Models](https://ai.info/news/mit-instructmesh-edit-ai-3d-models)
- [Meshy says print-preparation tool reduced defects in 3D test](https://ai.info/news/meshy-ai-3d-printability-benchmark)
- [U.S. agency seeks input on AI use in federal adjudications](https://ai.info/news/acus-seeks-input-ai-federal-agency-adjudications)
- [GAO says four AI platforms produced viable attack plans in tests](https://ai.info/news/gao-ai-platforms-viable-attack-plans-tests)
- [Suno adds paid image and video creation to its music platform](https://ai.info/news/suno-visuals-ai-image-video-music-platform)

## Explore

[More articles](https://ai.info/news)

---

Canonical: https://ai.info/news/voyager-ai-3d-models-printability-check
